Careers Wales Online logo
 

Professionals
Document Library  
Curriculum Support  
Quality Award  
  About the Award  
  Award Criteria and Good Practice  
 
    Student Achievement of learning outcome
 
 
    Overall Management
 
 
    People Management
 
 
    Partnerships, processes and resources
 
 
    Evaluation and continuous review
 
  Award Process  
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Get in touch with a Careers Adviser
 
  Professionals / Quality Award / Award Criteria / Evaluation and continuous review / Planned and co-ordinated approach to evaluation
Professionals  
Professionals  

  Planned and co-ordinate approach to evaluation
 
Sections
   Planned and co-ordinated approach to evaluation
 

CEG criteria
Evaluation of the careers programme is planned from the outset rather than an ad hoc process.

Those aspects evaluated will have a clear reason for being evaluated and effective methodology will be made use of in the evaluation process.

CEG evaluation should complement the whole establishment evaluation procedures and Estyn's self-assessment processes.
 

 

WRE criteria
Evaluation of the WRE programme is planned from the outset rather than an ad hoc process.

Those aspects evaluated will have a clear reason for being evaluated and effective methodology will be made use of in the evaluation process.

WRE evaluation should complement the whole establishment evaluation procedures and Estyn's self-assessment processes.
 

 
   

Evidence

  • Evaluation plan for WRE/CEG
  • Minutes of meetings where evaluation has been planned
  • Examples of evaluation tools
  • Discussion with staff

   
     
 

CEG notes
Not everything needs to be evaluated. Establishments are encouraged to build up an evaluation strategy by initially focussing on a small number of aspects that seem to need attention.
 

 

WRE notes
Not everything needs to be evaluated. Establishments are encouraged to build up an evaluation strategy by initially focussing on a small number of aspects that seem to need attention.
 

 
   Good practice guide

Traditionally evaluation has been rather an ad hoc activity - something 'tagged on' at the end of an event or programme. Evaluation now needs to be a major part of curriculum management and as such planned at the outset when the different aspects of the programme are being planned. For example a college starts to plan a HE workshop morning and whilst organising the practicalities also plans how to evaluate the effectiveness of the event against its intended learning outcomes.

A suggested way of planning evaluation
In order to evaluate a particular aspect of the careers or WRE programme the following process is suggested. This is based on ideas from Paul Davies.

  1. Background details
    Make a brief description of the activity, event or programme including details such as year group and student numbers, rationale, date and timings, employer involvement.
  2. Intended learning outcomes
    List the learning outcomes which students should have achieved through the activity.
  3. Focus/other issues
    What is the main area to be evaluated? Why are you evaluating this? Do not attempt to evaluate every aspect. Are there areas of particular concern?
  4. Methods of Data Collection
    Consider the most effective, and most user-friendly, method of collecting the data. This does not always need to be an evaluation form. There are many other techniques. The key consideration is 'fit for purpose'.
  5. Analysis and report
    The data collected should be used to make general conclusions about the effectiveness of the activity being evaluated. Look for common themes rather than try to include everything. If dealing with large numbers use percentages to indicate the significance of particular responses. Representative quotes, particularly from students, can be very effective.
  6. Discussion
    The evaluation report should be circulated to all relevant parties with a request for comments by a deadline. A useful technique is to attach a few questions to the report for readers to respond to. This makes it much more likely that it will be read.
  7. Next-Best Action
    The evaluation report should lead to some points of action. Write these as an action plan with deadlines and names next to each task. There should be a clear link between evaluation and development planning.

word QA - example of how to document the whole CEG programme including evaluation
word QA - evaluation plan proforma
word QA - example completed evaluation plan
word QA - coordinating your evaluation of CEG and WRE - example
word QA - lesson monitoring sheet
word QA - general good practice for evaluation
word QA - evaluation techniques
 
TOOLS & RESOURCES
  * e-Progress File
  * CV Wizard
  * Interview Games
  * Learning Choices
  * Career Ideas
  * Jobs in Wales
  * Job Outlooks
  * Weblinks
  * Contact Us
 
  * Clic Online
 
 
e-Progress File is an interactive tool to help you create and maintain your individual development record. Go!